In his insightful work, Richard Nisbett delves into the contrasting cognitive styles that have historically distinguished Eastern and Western thought. Ancient Greek philosophy, with its penchant for logic, sought to strip subjects from their contexts to forge a stable worldview. In stark contrast, ancient Chinese thought, through dialecticism, embraced the complexity of events, accepting contradictions and focusing on the interconnectivity of relationships. Nisbett's observations offer a compelling commentary on the current state of logic education within China, sparking a personal reflection on its apparent scarcity.
Drawing from my own experiences, I've observed a notable divergence in the educational emphasis on logic when comparing Chinese students to their Western counterparts. This observation is not a commentary on the intellectual capabilities across cultures but rather highlights the different approaches to problem-solving that are deeply rooted in distinct cultural philosophies. The diminished focus on logic within the Chinese education system can be attributed to several factors: a societal preference for emotional rapport, the Confucian values that prioritize harmony and loyalty within interpersonal relationships, and perhaps most significantly, the relentless pursuit of success within a test-centric educational framework.
Despite the rich tradition of logical thought in ancient China, its conspicuous absence in modern education warrants a thoughtful examination of the societal forces at play. My recent foray into D.Q. McInerney's "Being Logical — A Guide to Good Thinking" has further solidified my understanding of logic as an indispensable tool. McInerney employs accessible examples to elucidate fundamental logical theories and principles, underscoring the notion that logic extends beyond mere reasoning; it is a vital instrument in the quest for truth. Logic remains an essential component for anyone seeking to cultivate clear, efficient thought processes and to engage in effective communication across the myriad interactions of daily life. It is with this conviction that I advocate for a reinforced commitment to logic education within today's curricula, extending even to the prospect of lifelong learning in logic. Such an initiative is not only necessary but also holds profound implications for the intellectual and societal advancement of future generations.
试着读读呢?
Hofstede-Cultural-Dimensions-1.docx
Hofstede-Cultural-Dimensions-2.docx